top of page

Wise Wednesdays

Search

Should you speak or stay quiet?

4 days ago
2 min read

A couple of weeks ago, I coached someone through a dilemma about whether she should have spoken up. A group leader said something she felt deeply uncomfortable with, and she stayed quiet. It happened at the end of the meeting, and she left feeling confused, guilty, and ashamed.

The story she told herself was that she had let herself down and should have outgrown these people-pleasing patterns by now.


People often frame these situations as binary, either/or. The moment can feel so critical; our attention narrows and we become activated. Then, once we relax, a brilliant phrase for what we could have said emerges - but the moment has passed.


More often than not, I advocate for people to speak up: to face what is being avoided and name a boundary, need, or impact they've been holding back.


But this time, I sensed something else was at play.


Sometimes, these moments carry more nuance: both in terms of what is happening and how relationships function over time. They do not depend on a single event.


I shared the five principles of right speech from Buddhism with her and asked whether any of them applied to her dilemma.


Wise speech is:


  • True

  • Beneficial

  • Kind

  • Timely

  • Intended with goodwill


And they're best held lightly and with attention to context.


She felt an immediate sense of recognition and relief. She realised that while what she wanted to say may have been true, it may not have been beneficial or timely for her, the leader or the group. Suddenly, the situation looked less like a missed opportunity and more like a moment of deeper relational wisdom.


We’re often taught to frame situations in binaries: speak or stay quiet; you versus me; win or lose; succeed or fail. But life isn’t so rigid, especially when we’re evolving and situations are uncertain. These periods of life ask more of our capacity for complexity, ambiguity and seeing things from multiple perspectives.


Where might a dilemma in your life be more layered than it first appears? What’s it like to allow more nuance and possibility?


Have a great week,

Amina



Read from 400+ Wise Wednesdays on liberation in work, leadership, life:


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
We have not lost paradise.

What a week. I was at a health appointment when the doctor suddenly asked whether I could help him find his purpose. My reply: “Yes—but after we’ve finished our visits, to avoid a conflict of interest

 
 
 
Work less. | Wise Wednesdays

I’ve noticed a shift in why clients are coming to coaching - more space to reflect on important choices and do work that comes from a sense of soul rather than being imposed by a machine. Those themes

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page